by Adam Hartung | Oct 4, 2009 | Books, Defend & Extend, In the Rapids, In the Whirlpool, Lifecycle, Web/Tech
Do you remember when AOL dominated the internet? In the early 1990s most people who used the internet actually were AOL clients. They bought their internet access, via dial-up modems, from AOL. Their interface (browser) was from AOL. And most of the sites – and navigation – was driven by AOL. AOL was the "monster" of the web. And it created enormous value for investors from this leadership position. It's value stormed to over $160billion!
Chart from Silicon Alley Insider
But as we can see, once acquired by Time Warner AOL tried to Defend & Extend its position. These actions pushed AOL into the Swamp, an undefendable position in the rapidly growing internet world. Defending its position proved impossible, as people found better and lower cost solutions for accessing and using the web. Now AOL is in the Whirlpool, fast disappearing – an historical anecdote about early internet days.
Apple has only about 2% market share in mobile phones. On the one hand, this could appear nearly immaterial. But if we look at usage, we see a very different story
Chart courtesy Silicon Alley Insider
iPhone application growth, which is clearly becoming logarithmic, demonstrates a change in the marketplace. People are clearly using these devices for more than making calls. Unlike AOL, which tried to hold people into their environment – or even Motorola's RAZR which tried to dominate sales of phones with pricing – Apple isn't trying to Defend & Extend a market position. Apple is creating a market disruption by changing how mobile devices are used. Promulgating applications increases demand for the iPhone (and iTouch) as not just phones but as replacements for laptops and other internet devices. Possibly ereaders like Kindle. This pulls people toward Apple's devices, which will generate strong future growth. By constantly bringing out new uses, Apple disrupts the market for phones, computers and internet access devices. Positioning its own products to be big winners as demand continues growing, and keeping Apple in the Rapids.
PostScript –
I was pleased to see a recent Wall Street Journal article "What Kills Great Companies: Inertia." The message of Lock-in as a source of business problems keeps spreading. This time Gary Hamel talks about some of the sources of Lock-in he sees. Reads like he bought a copy of "Create Marketplace Disruption"!
by Adam Hartung | Aug 5, 2009 | Current Affairs, Disruptions, eBooks, General, Innovation, Leadership, Openness, Web/Tech
"Sony Unveils Pocket Size Electronic Book Reader" is the Los Angeles Times headline. According to Silican Alley Insider the new Apple tablet is a GREAT book reader. Although Steve Jobs thinks book publishers are incredibly screwed up and he's less optimistic about book sales than he was music sales when he launched iTunes. And Amazon has sold out its Kindle e-readers since they started manufacturing them two years ago.
With all these announcements, you'd think everyone knows about e-readers and the market shift happening in publishing – from books to magazines to newspapers. Even I've blogged about this for months – and the positive impact this has had on book sales as well as Amazon's revenues and profits. But:
(Link to chart and Forrester Discussion here)
Half of all people surveyed in 2Q 2009 still haven't seen or heard about e-readers.
This is important. Imagine it's 1983, and you weren't aware about personal computers and their benefits – even though the IBM PC was Time magazine's "Man of the Year" in 1982. We now know that early adopters of PCs developed new solutions for many problems – from analysis to word processing to advertising development to commercial graphics to in-house publishing to communicating via email — on and on and on. Those who understood this technology early, recognized the shift it demonstrated, had early advantages on competitors. You didn't have to compete in technology, or be a technology officianado, to take advantage of this computing shift for your advantage.
Today, ereaders are another serious market shift that early adopters can leverage. Soon newspapers and magazines will be hard to come by, or so thin (due to printing and distribution cost) that their content will be much less than desired. But ereaders allow you to keep up with journals you've come to trust. And advertisers need to be prepared to follow them onto this platform – to reach people they otherwise would miss.
If you've quit reading books because you don't have the money to spend (at $20+ apiece), desire to carry them, or the time to read them, ereaders allow you to buy and carry 350 or more books at a fraction of previous prices. You even can buy pieces of books (chapters for example) that give you what you want. Think of the shift from long-play albums/CDs to iTunes sales of single songs as an analogy. You can get the benefits of books without many of the reasons you may have quit reading them.
Would you like a repository of information you can call upon for your daily work? With e-readers you can carry an entire library, something you'll not do in paper. Or on your laptop.
Speaking of laptops – this will all be on a laptop you say – so forget ereaders. Do you really think we'll all be carrying these 7 pound monsters around in 5 years? Look at college kids today. How many do almost all their work on a phone? They use the computer only when forced to – for typing papers or building spreadsheets. Laptops are increasingly becoming much more than people want – too big, too heavy, too hot, too power hungry, too short battery life, too complicated, too much software, too many bugs, too many viruses, too expensive. Laptops will soon be like mainframes. Look at the trend. Sales of big screen laptops have cratered as netbooks, with tiny screens, have taken off. People are moving away from laptops to smaller and easier to use products – like ereaders.
Why make your salesforce, or customers, or training techs carry a laptop when an ereader will give them everything they need? They cost less, are easier to keep working, and don't get hindered with personal apps like MS Money that you didn't put on the laptop in the first place but couldn't stop. Given ereader prices, you might be able to consider an ereader disposable in 5 years. Literally, you could give a customer an ereader with all the training, specs, history, design elements, etc. of your product the way we now use a brochure. It literally might be cheaper than a 10 page glossy brochure costs to print and distribute – but with everything they need to design in your product, or operate it, or service it. Imagine an ereader in your car glove box rather than the owner's manual you never use – but the info will be catalogued, searchable, and linked to the internet so it's always current with service information.
Market shifts affect us all. Too often we say "oh that shift is obvious, and I'm surprised the current competitors aren't jumping on that." Then we ignore the shift ourselves. Competitors that make higher rates of return, and prolong those rates of return, observe these market shifts and immediately build them into future scenarios. They think about how to use these shifts to improve their competitive position, and create White Space to test the opportunities – even when they represent Disruptive change. These are Phoenix Principle companies – and the kind you want to be – because they grow more, make more money and have longer lives.
Learn how to spot market shifts and leverge them for your advantage. Don't end up like GM – out of touch and into bankruptcy. Read the new, free ebook "The Fall of GM: What Went Wrong and How To Avoid Its Mistakes."
by Adam Hartung | Jul 21, 2009 | Current Affairs, eBooks, General, In the Rapids
I've blogged before about the decline in book readership. In fact, the number of book stores has dropped some 20% in the last 3 years. It's not that people don't want to be learned. Rather, people no longer prefer to carry around a full length paper book. What was no big deal has become large, cumbersome and heavy. This isn't how we described books until we started reading everything imaginable on electronic devices. The new solutions made the old approach less desirable. The market shifted. And if books weren't available electronically, people would read other things which are available electronically.
Amazon wisened up and launched Kindle to meet this market shift. Good move, it allowed Amazon to keep growing while traditional format product sales declined. Now "Barnes & Noble launches on-line Kindle challenge" is the Financial Times headline. While Amazon keeps pushing new content onto Kindle, including newspapers and magazines, Barnes & Noble is maximizing the platforms it can reach electronically. Their solution, more software than hardware today, allows them to immediately offer 700,000 titles electronically. They now boast the largest on-line book store – somewhat eclipsing Amazon's early success. And their hardware device is yet to come.
Should Amazon be worried. I don't think so. The market for e-reading is growing extremely fast. With each new product generation the traditional market share shrinks as more people convert. At this stage, these companies are merely helping the market grow rather than competing with each other. That's the wonderful part about growth markets, – about being in the Rapids – there's so much new demand that it's less about competing head-to-head than about expanding the market by meeting more and more needs. Instead of slogging it out in trench warfare – which is the traditional book selling market – you can offer more features and ways to differentiate – thus growing the market. For both Amazon and Barnes & Noble this is a very, very good thing. It breathes growth into their businesses by moving into the shifted market space.
Borders was actually first to this market, linking up with the proprietary eReader from Sony. But Borders didn't move hard into the new market. As the weakest of the 3 leading book retailers, Borders should have moved fast to get out of the dying brick-and-mortar stores. Then used those resouces to take an early lead in the new market space. But the leaders at Borders kept trying to Defend & Extend the old business, and moved too slowly on the new business. Instead of getting out of the dying business, and becoming #1 in the growing business, they waited. Oops. Now Borders is again the weak competitor – and at grave risk of extermination.
The market is shifting. Congratulations to Amazon and Barnes & Noble for moving into the shifted market space. Quickly we'll be seeing fewer and fewer book stores on the street, as this business (similar to music) will become largely an on-line business. And better for us all. With cheaper books and other reading materials, maybe we'll continue to be even better read than previous generations.
Soon publishers and authors will have to step up to this shift. We all know that newspapers and magazines have been slow to adjust to this market shift. They should be begging for distribution on the Kindle device – and pushing B&N to get their device out even faster so periodicals can be distributed to them. Or maybe get their issues into the B&N software so people can read them on their laptops, netbooks or iPhones. The publishers, from newspapers to books, have been slow to understand this changed market. They, like recording publishers, are locked-in to the physical product (the CD for music, and paper for publishers). The winners will be those who move fastest to the new market. Sure, some people will always want print. But the market for digital is simply going to be lots, lots bigger. Best to get into that market today and figure out the new business model.
