Top oil industry executives were on Capital Hill yesterday being questioned about their profits (highest ever) and the tax breaks they receive for exploration and production. (Read AP report here under headline "Oil executives defend huge profits".) Let’s not be naive. As officers of their corporations, they have an obligation to maximize the value of their companies – otherwise they could be sued by investors. No matter their personal opinions, they have to defend their profits and their product prices. So reading that they did so should not be unexpected.
It’s not the headline that’s interesting, however. It’s how they reacted to questions about the future. After all, reported profits are the past. What does the industry see in the future, and how is it preparing for it?
Does anyone doubt that crude oil is being consumed faster than it is being produced? We’ve known that since – 1940! The 1970’s "oil price shock" certainly taught all of us that petroleum is a finite resource, and we’re using it up. It’s not whether we will run out of crude – but when. So the interesting question is, when will that happen and what are our biggest "energy" companies doing to prepare for it?
Unfortunately, this isn’t a big topic for these behemoths. Typical of the industry leaders, when the Chairman of BP America was asked what he wanted for America’s future he replied "We need access to all kind of energy supply" with the writer noting "adding that 85% of U.S. coastal waters are off limits to drilling." In other words, more of the same! Drilling more holes, possibly in environmentallyl dangerous locations, does not solve the real problem – world petroleum consumption keeps growing while the pools of oil underground are being used up.
Don’t get me wrong, I grew up in the Oklahoma oil patch. I had lots of relatives that poked holes in the ground, sold oil leases, and worked in oil companies. The industry was very good for my home state, creating jobs and raising the standard of living. But that was then. What we need to address is the future. What are these companies doing to replace these massive revenues as oil gets harder and more costly to find? What are their future scenarios, and how are they proposing to help create a wonderful future? Together, according to the article, the major oil companies spent $3.5b on other options besides oil last year (solar, wind, biodiesel). Their tax breaks – $18billion. Their profits last year $123b!
These companies are incredibly Locked-in. They aren’t energy companies, they are oil companies. Right now, they are making lots. But look at history, and they have sure had their down years (or, rather, decades). These companies are the sort that make good money 5 out of every 20 years. Oil companies have never been a great, consistent, long-term sort of investment. Right now, they are making a lot of money. Shouldn’t they be taking action to make the future better than the past? Wouldn’t it be good for investors, employees and customers if they invested in something besides more oil wells to improve their consistency and growth prospects? Wouldn’t all parties enjoy these companies developing a path to long-term success, even as the oil supplies diminish? As stewards of investor value for the long-term, don’t they need to have a resolution for growth besides merely higher prices? Don’t they need to find ways to actually make more energy and add real growth to their business?
Lock-in is allowing these companies to invest in a marginally declining value proposition. More holes, and more risk. They keep doing what they know how to do, what they’ve always done. What’s needed is White Space where the best minds could really work hard on new alternatives. These companies need to give real Permission to develop a new Success Formula – not just window dressing. The amounts they are investing are small not only compared to profits, but compared to the alternative investments they make in deep water drilling or inhosptible location projects. These oil projects as well cost in the billions of dollars. So the companies aren’t truly resourcing White Space either.
We all know the oil will run out. As investors, we should be looking for leaders that are seeking new ways to compete. New solutions. It will be the new solutions that create long-term above average rates of return. But these leaders didn’t exhibit much interest in anything but Lock-in and more of the same. And that’s too bad for the industry – and all of us customers as well.