WalMart (see chart here) has announced recent earnings, and they were better than Wall Street anticipated (read Marketwatch article here). Same store sales were up 3% compared to last year. As a result, the stock is worth today almost what it was worth 5 years ago (yet still more than 10% shy of all time highs from a decade ago.) Here we are in a terrible economy for retailers, with department stores, specialty stores and luxury stores all seeing double digit revenue declines. Yet WalMart comes in with a good quarterly result. Does this show WalMart is back on track to recapture past greatness?
WalMart has done nothing to make itself a better, more competitive company over the last year. It’s just done exactly what it has always done – but with a bit more price chopping than usual in some areas – and expansion of low-margin grocery sales in others. More of the same. For example, in the 30,000 person town of Minocqua, Wisconsin Wal-Mart opened a new store that was 5 times the previous store size and included a Wal-Mart grocery – offering the first competition to local grocers ever in that town. In other words, Wal-Mart kept being Wal-Mart.
Of course what happened was a recession. Certainly a recession in consumer spending. The decade of declining incomes in real terms met with the credit contraction of 2008, as well as declining home and auto values, reducing available cash for consumers. The immediate reaction was to simply buy less stuff – and become price sensitive. The first means people quit buying new diamonds and going to Aeropastale for sweatshirts, and the latter meant they started looking for where they could save dimes – not just dollars – on everything from sweatshirts to green beans. So where would you expect people to turn? Why to the retailer that has always been focused on saving dimes.
But this doesn’t mean Wal-Mart is the company you should invest in. Low-price is not the exclusive domain of Wal-Mart. I recently blogged about Aldi, a company that is even lower priced than Wal-Mart on groceries and is itself in an even bigger growth boom right now. And it’s doing new things (like its first-ever television advertising) to help itself grow. So Wal-Mart isn’t the only game in town for low-price. Competition to be the low-cost retailer will remain constant as other companies search out ways to be even lower cost than Wal-Mart – with strategies such as Aldi’s to carry a limited product line and use less labor (rather than just use cheap labor.)
More importantly, consumers don’t remain focused on price long-term. Recessions are characterized by job losses, hours worked reductions, bonus retractions and other income bashers. But things do move on. People don’t remain in a "recessionary mindset" forever. They change expenditure patterns and household budgets to get back into more comfortable lifestyles. And jobs, hours and bonuses come back. When that happens, the desire to shop WalMart will remain where it is now "only if I have to." Not a lot of high-schoolers want to show up in the sweatshirt everyone knows came from Wal-Mart, nor do many men want to purchase their work slacks at Wal-Mart. Now people feel they have to – it doesn’t mean they want to – nor that they’ll do it long term.
When short-term market shifts happen even a bad Success Formula can look good for a short while. Like the old phrase "even a stopped clock is right twice a day." Wal-Mart is extremely Locked-in to its one-horse strategy. Wal-Mart has not developed a culture which can adapt to the needs of modern consumers. It has not made its merchandizing modern, nor its store layouts, nor has it figured out how to adapt in-store selections to fit local market differences. Wal-Mart is still the company that controls the temperature in every store via thermostats in Fayetteville, Arkansas. The recent quarterly results are good news for the short-term, but do not reflect the out-of-date nature nor Lock-in of Wal-Mart’s Success Formula. By next year Wal-Mart will again be struggling to compete with more fashionable companies like Target, while fighting an even tougher batte on the price side with emerging competitors like Aldi.
If you bought Wal-Mart 5 years ago, you’ve been sitting on a paper loss (with almost no dividend return) for this whole period. Now’s the time to get out.