2006 has started with the completion of Viacom’s spin-off of CBS. Since these two entities merged, their value has about shrunk in half. What was to be an integrated media company is trying to increase its value by dis-integrating. Even Sumner Redstone, the legendary investor, said on CNBC Tuesday January 2 (when interviewed by Bob Pisani) that "Synergy is dead."
For at least 4 decades business leaders have believed that getting larger, especially by acquisition, was a good thing. If you couldn’t generate growth, fake out investors by buying it. But now we’re seeing companies face the opposite. Carl Icahn is after Time Warner to break up its business. And Knight Ridder is being forced to bust up its newspaper empire. All in order to "unleash the value" hidden in these merged organizations.
Congratulations! This is a great move to help these companies reinvigorate themselves. Not because of "focus", but because they can now quit focusing inward, trying to optimize their business models, and get back to the job of pleasing customers and adjusting to market requirements. The era of conglomeration was built on false assumptions that large companies could control their destiny and through optimization generating ever larger returns. Not! Instead, these companies lost touch with customers, became out of phase with their markets and prey for more nimble competitors while destroying shareholder value (not to mention the economic impact of thousands of lost jobs from downsizing, needless outsourcing and considerable "economic dislocation" for suppliers.)
Now, CBS and Viacom each needs to get about the job of creating a new Success Formula that aligns with customer needs. If they use this split as a Disruption, and put in place some White Space for new ideas to emerge, they have a great opportunity to catch up lost ground on emerging competitors and regain lost customers. They’ve moved the batter to first base – it’s time to see if they can move him around the bases to score.