Most managers want to move up.  It is characteristic to have ambition in organizations.  To want to do more, to accomplish more, and to receive more compensation.  So we look for opportunities to do more, inside our organizations and outside.  Usually we move positions because we don’t have upward mobility internally, so we find the opportunity externally.  But, not all upward moves are worth the risk.

Look at the revolving door installed by Mr. Lampert at the executive suite of Chicago headquarted Sears (see chart here).  (Read more about another round of Sears executive changes here.)  Mr. Lampert has convinced some very talented people to take top positions at Sears.  He has hired people away from companies as well known as Yum Brands, Motorola, Proctor & Gamble,  Now he’s hoping that a new crop of execs will save the company from its perilous slide which has cut equity value more than 50% in the last year.  But, rather than becoming business saviors, these new executives will probably be limiting their careers when Sears continues to falter. 

It’s the nature of leaders to be optimistic.  To think they can accomplish what previous managers couldn’t.  And some are better than others.  But we should eschew the "hero" complex entirely when looking at a new position.  Success will have more to do with circumstances than us as individuals.  And when a business is struggling, like Sears, it’s only hope to turn around requires it give up looking in the rear view mirror at old advantages and focus completely on the future.  It must be clear about competitor strengths, and ignore the temptation to think of customers as an asset.  It must Disrupt the old Lock-ins, and nullify the Status Quo Police.  And it must implement White Space where the manager has permission to do whatever it takes to succeed – unbounded by old Lock-ins – as well as the resources committed in advance to accomplish the goals.  Without those 4 things, success is not going to happen.  No matter how good you are. 

Looking at Sears and Mr. Lampert we know a few things.  He keeps talking about the old Sears advantages, and trying to find a way to recapture them.  He’s trying to plan for the past, not the future.  Meanwhile, he isn’t looking for new customers by being a cutting edge competitor, instead he’s trying to hang onto old customers and Defend them from better competitors.  Thirdly, he likes to "whack the chicken coop" by making lots of noise and firing people, but he’s not willing to Disrupt old processes, practices and behaviors in order to nullify the Status Quo.  And Fourthly, he absolutely doesn’t have any White Space as he keeps trying to fiddle with the old Sears to improve it.  Rather than create White Space he shuts it down in cost cutting actions while trying to "fix" a hopelessly out of date Success Formula.

Those who left good jobs to go to Sears for Mr. Lampert have not escalated their careers.  And the new batch of managers he’s hired will fare no better.  Sears under Mr. Lampert is not following The Phoenix Principle to turn itself around, but rather keeps trying to find some way that it can be cheaper, faster, better and thus Defend & Extend what worked 30 years ago. 

If you want to make a career move, do not listen to the Siren’s song about how everything can be different if the right person is in the job.  Circumstances make more difference than the person.  We work in organizations that have powerful Lock-in to behaviors, structural systems and cost.  Unless the primary pieces of successful change are there, no individual will make much difference.  Yes, it’s good to want to get ahead.  But make sure you don’t take a job where your head will be handed to you.