What Bill Clinton said – and it was all about making profit
Saturday I had the good fortune to attend a presentation by President Bill Clinton. He spoke at the Indian Institute of Technology alumni conference – an event I attended as a speaker myself.
President Clinton must have used the word profit 100 times. In today's divided political climate with words like "socialism" bandied about you might be surprised. But his talk focused on the importance of making a profit as businesses meet customer needs.
The 42nd President discussed how new fish farms in Haiti were important to improving the devastated economy – because they allowed everyone involved to make a profit. He discussed how forests devastated for charcoal were being replaced by a new business that converted used paper and sawdust into a charcoal replacement for 75% less cost to the user — and yet created over 100 good paying jobs and produced a profit. His point was simple, you can't fix a down-and-out country's economy unless there is a profit in it. And he was seeing, through his foundations, multiple profit opportunities.
Across the board, the President reminded listeners that they can maintain the profit motive and solve big problems if they think about the business differently. American competitiveness is seriously challenged by rising health care costs. Yet Pennsylvania has shown it can contain costs by reporting cost and outcome statistics – a practice not shared in the other 49 states. Switzerland has a private health care system, and it incorporates wellness programs, but it spends only 11% of GDP on health care. The U.S. spends 17%. The U.S. needs to rethink how health care is sold and administered first – and if it does that private enterprise can continue to lead. But it takes a shift on the part of the health care insurers and providers.
After many years as the country with the highest percentage of college graduates in the 25 to 34 age group, in the last 8 years America has fallen to 10th. America has priced college out of the range of too many students, while other countries have modifed their approach and improved completion rates. To improve competitiveness requires an educated society. It takes different thinking if America is to regain strength as an educated country. Now that American competitiveness is being challenged (the theme of this meeting) the former President challenged whether that competitiveness can be regained if we don't think differently about how we provide education.
Of all his comments, I most enjoyed his discussion about how much . Americans love zero sum games. He and then pointed out that almost all games (football, soccer, etc.) have been modified to allow for overtimes so somebody wins. He brought up an Arkansas football game that went to 7 overtimes! Americans hate non-zero sum situations, where multiple people can win, or where it's possible to win by doing things differently. But he pointed out that in life, almost nothing is a zero sum game. That is limited to the sports field. Even in battles, it's often not clear who the winner is – for both sides will declare victory. He commented "all economic systems carry the seeds of their own destruction." And when it comes to succeeding in business you don't need to create a zero sum game. You can succeed by doing things differently.
Far too many business gurus discuss business like it is zero sum. For example, Jim Collins' BHAG and his love of fighting for a "hedgehog" concept is all about viewing business as a zero-sum game that you have to win. But today most growing, high return businesses intentionally avoid zero-sum games. Those lead to price wars and declining returns. Instead they (like Google) employ innovation, like the folks making charcoal from recycled paper, to develop new solutions that are superior and earn higher returns.