The Marketing Executives Network Group (site here) has just released its second annual top marketing trends study (read press release and overview here, and study results here). Kudos to MENG for keeping up the effort – and especially so given the surprising results.
Many people think marketers lead their customers. Often, employees think marketers are the people charged with being ahead of customers, scanning the horizon for market shifts that can affect future sales. The perception is that marketers are looking for ways to Disrupt markets, introducing new technologies, products and services to generate competitive advantage. But the results of this survey show that isn't exactly what's going on – at least today. Statistically, according to responses, it appears that most marketers are firmly Locked-in to Sustaining past company sales. The results indicate that the 650 people responding to this survey are more deeply rooted in the past than in the changes now happening which are affecting results at many businesses to their core.
- The #1 business book was considered Good To Great by Jim Collins, and #2 was The Tipping Point by Malcolm Gladwell. No doubt, both of these books have been big sellers. But, the first was published in 2001, and the second in 2000 – neither are exactly "latest thinking" about business, marketing or innovation. Worse, both have been extensively reviewed in academia – and despite their popularity have been proven to be without merit as guidebooks for success. While their logic is appealing, when backtested and when applied, both led to worse results, rather than better, than average. Rosenzweig even has taken the time to publish The Halo Effect which is dedicated to disproving the validity of Mr. Collins (and other's) tales as benefactors of increased sales or profits. A book not even on the list.
-
As gurus, the marketers like Seth Grodin, Warren Buffet and Malcolm Gladwell in the first 3 spots, with Tom Friedman in fifth. Again, interesting array. While Seth has an MBA, he was never a successful marketer – until he started selling short books with catchy titles and simple answers for complex problems. Malcolm Gladwell and Tom Friedman neither have any business training or business experience at all – both having been writers and editors by academic training and career (The New Yorker and The New York Times, respectively). I asked Malcolm what led him to write "The Tipping Point" and he said "you get paid a lot more to write a catchy business book than to do serious writing." And Warren Buffet is famous for his total disdain for marketing. As he said in an interview once "if you have to spend on marketing your product doesn't sell itself – so what good is it? Marketing dollars can be spent better elsewhere."
-
By far the #1 target market is considered Baby Boomers. Interesting, given that all studies show that as Boomers are nearing and entering retirement their spending (in dollars, and as percent of income) is declining precipituously. Neither Gen X or Gen Y received more than 2/3 the interest of Boomers – even though both are driving more consumption individually than the long-focused-upon but aging Boomers. Given that by 2015 there will be more non-European ancestry Americans than European, hispanics were only 76% as interesting as Boomers, and Asians were only 1/3 as interesting. With President-elect Obama taking the most recent election while losing a majority of the Boomer vote – yet winning the younger and the non-white vote, it is interesting where these marketers showed a preference to focus.
-
Aligned with other responses, these marketers felt that Marketing Basics were the #1 issue for marketers, more than twice as important as innovation or "green"and more than 3 times as important as using technology. Further, the leading disliked buzzwords included Web 2.0, Social Networking, Social Media, Blogs and Viral marketing. Yet, the President-elect pulled off an incredible upset primarily by jumping past the old marketing basics and using the latter techniques to reach a new audience, build an amazing brand and create intense loyalty surpassing much better known and initially better funded competitors. At the same time, in 2008 MTV stopped running music videos entirely because they could not compete with YouTube.com, and blogs have shown the ability to spread messages at a fraction of the speed used by traditional advertising or public relations
There is no doubt business saw a lot of change happen in 2008. And we all expect considerable additional change in 2009. But it would appear that the marketers in this study are customers of their own product – potentially to a fault. Old brands (Collins, Buffett, Boomers) still captivate their attention, while newer, upcoming trends and messages are considered far less interesting. As market shifts are happening, they seem more interested in defending past marketing approaches than moving to the front edge of what's working in a rapidly changing, digitized, globally competitive marketplace.
There's no doubt that a lot of marketing is about sustaining an existing business. In most companies, Defending & Extending old products, old brands and old distribution systems get the lion's share of attention. Unfortunately, this behavior can set up many companies to be "knocked off" by emerging competitors who don't operate by the old rules, or in the same way. Google paid absolutely no attention to the gentlemanly behavior of the media as it systematically pulled advertisers to the internet – leaving newspapers and magazine publishers to decline, merge, declare bankruptcy and completely fail. It's these Disruptive competitors, using new techniques, that today are putting many of our oldest businesses at risk.
At times of great change, great opportunity emerges. Someone has to lead the charge for identifying these opportunities and moving forward. Success cannot happen by trying to Defend old Success Formulas after market change makes their rates of return sub-optimal. For many of us, we want to turn to marketers. And my guess is that marketers ARE the best people to discern these opportunities, and take the lead. It's important that now, more than ever, we encourage them to lead customers, rather than follow old markets. Now, when investing in legacy brands, products and technologies is suffering rapidly declining returns, is when we most need our marketers to take to the forefront of exploration and chart a course toward new markets and opportunities.